Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Mavericks, Geniuses and Bozo the Clown


What would you say or do if you found your kid running out the door when there was a raging storm outside? What would you say or do when you saw your kid plucking out an earthworm from the kitchen garden and putting it in his mouth? What would you say when you heard that someone insisted that the Earth was not the centre of the Universe? Or that the world indeed was round and not flat as was widely believed at the time? How many of us congratulate our kids when they come home to tell us that they have dropped out of school to pursue butterfly watching? Or as is happening more often these days (or so I hear) to become a rock star?

All these people existed in the past, walk the Earth today and will be born in the future. And many of these people changed the world. So, my question is when did they stop being unruly, rebellious, not knowing what they really wanted, did not listen to the world, essentially more akin to Bozo the Clown when compared to their more “illustrious” peer group, to becoming what they ultimately did become by what they accomplished.

When we look at a child we see this little bundle of joy, learning how to take their first tentative steps with their parents holding on to their little arms. Parents who at that very young age give them the confidence to take that first step. And then the next. The look of amazement and joy and wonder of any parent who has witnessed his or her child’s first steps is something that lives on for a very long time. The parent, along with the infant, are also taking their first steps. There are no authoritative books written on bringing up children and for each set of parents, for every child in the Universe, it is journey of discovery. Of adventure. Of amazement.

And then the parents grow up. Doubts come into their minds. Protecting their children from the big bad world outside becomes their top priority. They do not want the child to get hurt. And the little bundle of joy gets more and more isolated from the real world, parents start taking the decisions and a life of dependence slowly crawls into their world, misting their environment. If something does go wrong, the parents are always there to soften the effect by taking the blow themselves.

But a child has a way of growing up too. S/he goes to school, s/he makes new friends and gets exposed to a world outside of home, learns of a life different from his/her own. Ideas take ground, but often do not find the soil to germinate in the cushioned and carpeted confines of home. Often times a rebel is born. As s/he grows older, the rebel grows wings in manners that manifest in different ways.

One way is the rebel gets a voice is by questions. Authority is questioned. Rules are questioned. Laws are not sacrosanct anymore. The answer to the question “Why is the sky blue” is not shut down by a retort “Sit down and finish your meal”.

For some of these rebels the questions find a firm fertile soil and take ground. The rebel starts questioning the whys and hows and why nots of the world. The answers are few and the questions are many. Many get left by the wayside, joining the teeming millions in their race to put food on the table. For but a tiny few the quest continues.

There is a very thin line between finding the answer and not finding it. For those who do not, there are monikers that get annexed to their name – Maverick, Basketcase, Silly, Stupid, Crazy. And then there are those who get a different nickname – GENIUS. And that is where Ben Franklins and Albert Einsteins and Galileos and Edisons are exposed to the rest of the word. They become the successful people. They are the ones about who books are written and syllabi designed around. It was just that one small step in the continuity of time that worked in their favour that turned them from being a maverick to a genius.

Do you doubt that there is a genius in everyone? I don’t. It is just that we do not provide the opportunity for that genius to flourish. Of course luck plays a very big role in success. The right place. The right time. The right person sitting in front of you. The right colour of the money backing your thoughts. A lot of things need to come together. There are only a small fraction of successes, but that does not mean that we stop the questions emanating from the minds and hearts of a young child who is just about entering this unique, crazy, confusing world, trying to find answers to this madness around, trying to work out in that small brain how to make it a better place for everyone.

And then we turn back and call him Bozo the Clown. Who knows which Bozo the Clown will grow up to be the one to find a way to settle in Mars. Or the cure to cancer. Or maybe just how to make the rose smell nicer. Let us give Bozo the Clown all the support s/he needs and not shroud a possibly bright future down in clouds of ignorance and fear.

Long live Bozo the Clown.

Friday, August 15, 2008

Democracy doesn’t win wars

It is coincidental that today, August 15, we celebrate the Independence Day of the world’s largest democracy. It is indeed something to be extremely proud of, our democracy that is. We citizens, each and every one of us, have a voice. We can demand that our voice be heard. There are enough examples in our neighbourhood where this fact is not true. And the democracy we take for granted so easily, is subverted by many governments around the world. Long live India and long live this vibrant democracy.

But sometimes it makes me wonder. This complacency. Do we take freedom for granted. Do we not realise that with freedom comes responsibility? And accountability? Do we not owe something back to this society that comprises each and every one of us? Why do crib and curse the famous ‘system’ and sit back and perpetuate the problem. Why don’t we stand up and do something about it?

But that is another debate and the subject I am dealing with is democracy and its importance in times of crises. Can a democratic set-up win a war? Let us take an example. The enemy is deeply embedded in a hill feature, above us. We are out numbered and the enemy is better equipped. A battalion is entrusted with the responsibility of capturing the hill feature. Let us see democracy at work…

The platoon commander who will lead the assault comes to the battalion commander and requests a meeting who in turn calls his Brigade Commander who asks him to wait for some time. The Brigade Commander radios the Divisional Commander who then confers with his Corps Commander.

(And remember all this is conscientiously minuted, in triplicate, and filed and receipts taken.)

The Army Commander sets up a Committee who meet to discuss the best way forward, the possible alternative methods of attacks that will offer the best chances of success. The Committee publishes a White Paper after three days and sleepless nights (it is war, after all) and sends it to the Cabinet Committee on Security for their approval. They spend another couple of days on the White Paper and finally the Parliamentary Committee on External Affairs tables it in Parliament for approval. Of course, this is after a special session of Parliament is called to debate the issue. Finally, the action is approved and the document containing approval of the assault on the hill is passed down the chain of command to the platoon commander who is waiting for the command to go ahead. But then, by this time, the enemy has run over the post and a new set of battle plans have to drawn up and sent to Parliament for approval.

This is an exaggerated example but isn’t this pretty much how to democratically fight a war? I am convinced that there is a need for democracy and that is what binds us citizens together. But at the same time, in times of crises, there is need for a strong hand, an iron will, nerves of steel, a time for split second decisions and the orders better be obeyed, or else there could be hell to pay. A war is won by a dictator. And the dictator is the person in charge on the frontline. The man who is leading his men to their death … or glory.

Democracy does not and can not win a war. Democracy comes into play after the battle has been won. When democrats, bureaucrats, politicians, citizens, come forward to pay respects to the martyrs and to rejoice the gallant soldiers. Till then, we need a dictator to win the war.

Are we in the middle of a crisis? Is our great country being compromised due to the democracy we hold so dear? Is it time to take some steps to stem the rot that is setting in before it is too late? Was it necessary for the trouble in Kashmir over the Amarnath issue growing out of hand? No, say many. Can the Kashmir extremism be wiped out? In about two months, I have heard people say who have the means to do it. Problems based on religious lines, education issues, sporting issues, et al. Many of these are examples of democracy gone sour. We the people need to stand up and ensure that the greatness of our country that has endured for thousands of years is not compromised.

Let us remember that when we are at war, it is not democracy that we need. Jai Hind.